I haven’t been a fan of lock washers since I read Carroll Smith’s
Prepare to Win in which he’s pretty disparaging of them. I think they can be effective based on the experience of a buddy of mine:
One of his first projects out of engineering school was to find out why a machine was shaking itself literally to pieces. Actually, nothing was working, not split lock washers nor even nylon lock nuts but the “points” on the lock washers actually dug into the nut and the piece before they let go. That tells me that in a less severe environment, they would have done their job.
It doesn’t seem that all split lock washers are designed to dig in like those lock washers and so if I had to choose one, I’d use AN (aircraft) lock washers purely because if it was designed to be used on an airplane, it would be more likely to work. If I was really worried about vibration, I would used safety wire or Loctite - usually safety wire because it is absolutely effective and it is a visual indication later that that bolt was tightened properly. I also think it looks cool!
Admittedly, it is over kill on a road car and is a pain in the ass to do and undo.
Just my thoughts on lock washers…