I got my 73 Twin Cam Special almost three years ago and have been working on it hit and miss since but not during the winters since I don't have a heated work area. The motor was partially disassembled and not in the car when I took possession in August of 2019. It is now back together and the motor is running, ready for me to begin road driving as soon as I can sort a problem with the transaxle, a 365.
Sitting in the car with no motor running, reverse, third, fourth and fifth are easily accessed, although the linkage has a vagueness to it that leaves a lot to be desired. When trying to access first or second, I have to make multiple attempts at it, kind of like fishing for the right linkage position. The first attempts are met with a blocked path but eventually it goes into what seems to be the correct position.
With the motor running, all of this is the same but what seems to be first and second are really third and fourth gears and I come to this conclusion based on revving the engine and slipping the clutch to get moving. My tachometer is not connected right now so that's not available as a reference. I've attached a video that provides a view of the action from the rear of the transaxle with some description of what's happening. This appears to show first and second being engaged when in fact, they are not. With the motor running and me in the car, I have yet to engage either first or second gears.
Based on a thread form this site a while ago, I'm using Swepco 210 multi grade gear oil in the transaxle. I even thought cold oil might be the problem so I let the car idle in neutral for a while to get the gear oil warmer. This had no effect.
When I bought the car, it had set idle since perhaps 1976 and was partially disassembled. The odometer read 22,000 miles and I have no reason to think that was not accurate. So, given the choice to go after the transaxle while the motor was at the machine shop, I chose not to, thinking it was in good condition.
I'm anything but a transaxle expert, with almost no understanding of how they work. I have a career mechanic who helps me and is confident we can solve the problem by taking the trannie out of the car, disassembling it and diagnosing then correcting the problem. I have lots of confidence in his help but he's never been in one of these either.
I also thought it might be worn linkage bushings , although the motion seemed to be pretty tight. The one at the base of the shifter was all but gone so I replaced it. The one at the universal joint seemed in good order but I replaced it anyway. This improved the feel of the shifting motion but had no effect on the first and second issue.
So, I'm looking for help with this and hoping someone on the site can help with an understanding of the problem.
Can't attach the video right now because of file type and size. I will try to solve this issue and then post it later.
Thanks Footer