When I needed to replace them in the rear arches I used 1" thick styrofoam. I cut them to shape and fit them in place, then secured them with some expanding foam insulation. Once the foam insulation hardened, I trimmed it with an Olfa blade. It looked a bit out of place, being white, but it quickly 'naturalised' and became unnoticeable. At car shows, the well initiated were amused to find the styrofoam, given the lightweight nature of the car.
It was just a 'work-around' at the time, using materials I had on hand on the day before a club cruise, during which rain was expected. However the styrofoam solution has grown ion me, and I will be replacing all of them similarly eventually. Taking a que from Arizona's comments above, I may experiment with adding a cladding of fibreglass resin for durability, though having said that, the existing unit has been in place for over six years and thousands of miles now. Extremely light and easy to fit.