I'll start off by saying it's many years since I ran anything with a vac. advance, so if this is a dopey suggestion, please cut me some slack
Normally timing doesn't move at all once set, so my take would be that something's changed, either you've done it inadvertently or maybe whatever internal advance the Renault distributor has might have decided to stick on full advance. That's based on the comment that it's pinking at lower revs (over advanced) but going well on high revs where normally you'd expect to get maximum advance.
JB's suggestion to plot a "revs vs advance" chart should tell you if you're effectively getting full (or almost full) advance at lower revs. If that's the case then I'd be looking to see if there's something broken/sticking with the timing advance weights or springs in the distributor (assuming the Renault uses weights that is ?)
I also found this service bulletin in my files which was issued for the S2. I've no idea if the advance data is relevant to your engine but I'll post just in case it is.