Chuck, the new seals from seals direct fit fine on the passenger door and on the drivers door needed to be adjusted tighter on the leading edge of the door (at the windshield A pillar) to prevent seeing any daylight. So the adjustment of the doors is important. I drove my car in the rain twice and never had a leak.
With the seals from RD I could never get the doors to close properly without a major push and I worried about cracking the fiberglass or breaking something. It seems others have installed, slammed the door and just let the rubber compress over time. I would imagine if you live in a rainy climate these seals would function better over time (they are wider and sit more proud providing greater surface area at the seal).
Considering my car lived mostly in the garage and used primarily on sunny days, the seals I used were a great option.
I can’t tell you how much effort it took to get the doors Installed and adjusted with the gaps equal on all sides. Plan on spending a day per door and you will not get frustrated. And having a helper is almost a must.
Chuck, I thought your still in the primer phase on your car? Wait until it’s completely painted to install doors. As a matter of fact, wait until the whole car is completely assembled until installing the doors (including the interior carpet).