Lotus Europa Community

Lotus Europa Forums => Garage => Topic started by: TurboFource on Saturday,June 22, 2024, 04:45:20 AM

Title: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: TurboFource on Saturday,June 22, 2024, 04:45:20 AM
Wanted to see what forum members are using and are they happy with it?
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: jbcollier on Saturday,June 22, 2024, 05:06:57 AM
I use an LM1 from Innovate Motorsports.  Works like a charm.  Would get the newer version if buying agin, of course.  I have tuned cars, motorcycles and even hopped up 2 strokes with it.  A real game changer for tuning engines easily and properly.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Clifton on Saturday,June 22, 2024, 06:14:14 AM
I had an original LM-1 hand held that had the box. They were the first that had an affordable wideband. It had to calibrate often. I'm sure the newer ones are better. I use an AEM classic wideband now. They have come out with the X band that is thinner too.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: BDA on Saturday,June 22, 2024, 09:46:46 AM
Has anyone seen this one: https://www.plxdevices.com/PLX-Wideband-O2-Air-Fuel-Ratio-Sensor-Modules-Gauges-s/125.htm. It looks interesting and reasonably priced.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Kendo on Saturday,June 22, 2024, 12:08:50 PM
Whichever system you buy, is the bung that gets welded into the exhaust pipe the same size and thread for all of them? Is there a metric/imperial difference to watch out for?
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: TurboFource on Saturday,June 22, 2024, 01:11:26 PM
I believe all O2 sensors have the same thread M18 x 1.5
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Pfreen on Sunday,June 23, 2024, 03:53:57 AM
I use the AEM 30-4110.  It works great.  I think all of them use either the Bosch sensor or NGK.  I don't think the electronics or display is the problem.  The sensor is the challenge.  Mine uses the Bosch sensor.   No complaints.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: 314159td on Sunday,June 23, 2024, 07:41:14 PM
I've been running this Glowshift unit (https://www.amazon.com/dp/B007GE8I7K) (‎GS-T702W) for some time now. Iirc came with a name-brand Bosch sensor and standard connector. Be wary, some of the complete kits use a proprietary or otherwise annoying to source connector, so if you need to replace the sensor it's extra annoying to get things connected.

I have it about 10" from the closest exhaust port on my Corvair, against their recommendations, as there's nowhere else for it to go. Has been fine for 3K+ miles. Recalibrated it for the first time recently and it seems like nothing changed.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: jbcollier on Monday,June 24, 2024, 05:14:52 AM
I wouldn’t leave them hooked up permanently.  We are not running full race engines where the jetting goes off of the sun goes behind a cloud.  Just use them to jet your carb and then take them out.  You’ll be tuning for “proper” operation (on the rich side) and this means more deposits than O2 sensors normally like, which will reduce their life.

I disagree about where to place the priority when choosing a gauge.  The suggestion of PLX above for example.  Lots of complaints about lack of support and a poorly designed app.  You want a company that supports you and their product, not a 10 minute tech wonder.  It is difficult to get meaningful info off the web and review sites are over represented by unhappy/ignorant users.  Feedback from people with personal experience, and have used their equipment a lot, is much more useful.

Lastly, a blue tooth link would be very handy but how well does it work with unshielded electrical systems?  Just be a little cautious.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: TurboFource on Monday,June 24, 2024, 07:24:16 AM
Thanx to all for their input!
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Clifton on Monday,June 24, 2024, 07:26:28 AM
I use the AEM 30-4110.  It works great.  I think all of them use either the Bosch sensor or NGK.  I don't think the electronics or display is the problem.  The sensor is the challenge.  Mine uses the Bosch sensor.   No complaints.

Same unit I'm running. Some of the other brands have a control box. I can only speak of the AEM, they do not. The gauge is the controller too. Just two plugs on the back. I leave mine in all the time as I am EFI, boosted, tune able and need to know. 14 years on a bunch of engines with no problems.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: BDA on Monday,June 24, 2024, 08:37:39 AM
... The suggestion of PLX above for example.  Lots of complaints about lack of support and a poorly designed app.  You want a company that supports you and their product, not a 10 minute tech wonder.  It is difficult to get meaningful info off the web and review sites are over represented by unhappy/ignorant users.  Feedback from people with personal experience, and have used their equipment a lot, is much more useful.

Lastly, a blue tooth link would be very handy but how well does it work with unshielded electrical systems?  Just be a little cautious.

Thanks for that, JB! I was considering the PLX as a possible purchase and seeing that it is negatively viewed potentially saved me from wasting money and being really frustrated!
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Grumblebuns on Wednesday,June 26, 2024, 02:37:39 PM
For those of you who have it, how do you collect data for later analysis. Trying to observe the AFR meter on the fly and trying to remember the data is near impossible. How do you hook up a laptop for this. Most of the YouTube videos are for newer cars using OBD ports.   
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: BDA on Wednesday,June 26, 2024, 02:40:43 PM
You could check on https://vintagetechnologygarage.groups.io/g/sidedraft. Keith does a lot of work with them.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Kendo on Wednesday,June 26, 2024, 03:29:35 PM
The LM-2 logs directly to an SD card, I assume for later analysis. https://www.innovatemotorsports.com/lm-2-basic-kit.html (https://www.innovatemotorsports.com/lm-2-basic-kit.html)
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Grumblebuns on Wednesday,June 26, 2024, 04:10:57 PM
The LM-2 at almost $600 may be more than I need for tuning the Strombergs and later the Mikuni conversion. The basic AEM A/F system has provision and wiring for a DB-9 connector is under $200. For our basic carburated cars is there any reason to pay all of the bells and whistles that the more expensive unit have? I found this YouTube video of an AEM system on a classic Mini.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BbXO_l4srP4&list=PLVI6drejxJECGwyBigXJilhD8uFKf1vpL&index=7

I'll also check out Vintage Technology to see what Keith is doing
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Kendo on Wednesday,June 26, 2024, 04:34:25 PM
BUT, do you even have a computer that has a DB-9 connector? (Just joking, RS-232 will never die)
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Kendo on Wednesday,June 26, 2024, 04:35:53 PM
BTW, I'll be getting one to tune existing Strombergs and a future Mikuni conversion. So I'll watch yuor progress with interest.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: jbcollier on Thursday,June 27, 2024, 06:01:24 AM
When you are jetting a carb, you don’t do “everything” at once.  You follow a process.  I work on one thing at a time.  A quick glance at the gauge is all that is required.
Title: Re: What wideband O2 A/F gauge would you recommend?
Post by: Clifton on Thursday,June 27, 2024, 06:40:23 AM
The basic AEM A/F system has provision and wiring for a DB-9 connector is under $200. For our basic carburated cars is there any reason to pay all of the bells and whistles that the more expensive unit have? I found this YouTube video of an AEM system on a classic Mini.
/quote]

I used my AEM WB on two carburated bikes, 225cc and a 400cc, taped it to the bars. All AEM's have a 0-5v output but you need something, an ECU to accept it to log.  IMO logging really isn't needed with a carb. It is helpful if you want to log say a drive or WOT run and look back, great on efi when you can change so many load points but on a carb you won't have rpm and airflow data overlapped with it. The LM1 did/may still have input's for rpm and configurable 0-5v inputs for TPS etc but the cost isn't justified for the need. Logging is also good if you have enough power that glancing at a gauge at WOT takes too long to be safe.

What jbcollier said is so true, "A quick glance at the gauge is all that is required."